Who is Shepard Book?

Have you ever wanted to go back into a situation and be a fly on the wall?  See what was happening on the other guy’s end of the story?

I have. Like all of you, I ask myself, “Who is Shepard Book?” What do we know?

 

Shepard Book:

  • Was a priest for a long time
  • Knows just when to step in and when to stay to himself
  • Thinks through situations
  • Always intelligent when he speaks
  • Has an impressive security clearance
  • Knows a lot about key bad guys
  • Has military weapons skills

My theory?

Shepard Book is a fly on the wall; a very specific, very interesting fly on the wall. This fly would have to

  • be untraceable
  • be able to control emotions, not get involved personally
  • understand religion in order to keep a good cover as a shepard
  • be patient; to discover what he is searching for

I stewed these ideas around in my brain for a while I came up with:

My Theory of Shepard Book’s Origins

I suggest that Shepard Book is none other than: The Operative

The Operative disappeared.  He doesn’t exist in any databank, but his Ident Card can clearly get him anything he wants.

Shepard Book has no origins.  He doesn’t exist in any databank but his Ident Card can clearly get him anything he wants.

The Operative is measured, quietly telling each of his victims what their sins are. He has strong faith and believes that he is ridding humanity of evil.  At the end of everything The Operative’s faith is shaken.

Shepard Book is tempered and quietly religious.  Book has been “a long time away”.  During River’s mind probing, Book says, “I don’t give half a hump if you’re innocent or not, so where does that put you?”, not exactly preacher talk and a far cry closer to assassin talk.

The Operative has vital information about the people he is sent to assassinate, their ways, and the ways of the people that interact with them.  He gets enjoyment from being several steps ahead of his victims.

Shepard Book knows a heap about the bad guys like Nitcka and Shan Yu.  He moves the plot along with his ability to know what to look for and where to find it before anyone else knows there’s a question what needs askin’.  Book was clearly tagged as not a preacher by the bounty hunter, and he has a working knowledge of weaponry even though he’s a preacher….

Also, Shepard Book’s journey with the crew ends just before The Operative comes into their lives. Therefore, I conclude that Shepard Book is The Operative who somehow (we are in science fiction after all) went back and became the proverbial fly on the wall.

Maybe a bubble, maybe a freak storm that shot time traveling lightning at him, maybe the Alliance Federation discovered time travel and wanted a test dummy so he volunteered.

Who knows?   And who knows when?  Maybe a couple days before we see him board Serenity or maybe several years.  Maybe he searches for or maybe he just stumbles upon Serenity.  Either way, without changing any courses or revealing any information, he gets to see Mal and his crew as they were before he knew of them.  He gets to be a fly on the wall.  But not just a fly on the wall, a member of the crew he admired.  And of course, he is killed without having ever revealed his true identity.

Is this really who he is?  I don’t know…but hopefully one day we’ll find out!

Comments

  1. BenDover says:

    Even before the Serenity-movie I thought he had been some kind of special intelligence officer, or to borrow the term from the Bourne films, an asset for the most secretive parts of the government.

    The reason why Book understood so well why the Operative acted the way he did, was because he used to be one. The Alliance would have several such Operatives active at any given time, with various degrees of security clearance. At some point Book had enough, and retired to a convent, where he spent probably a fairly long time, before he left to see to world again, and grouped up with the crew of the Firefly.

    • Beamer says:

      This is where My thought pattern runs also. (BTW men go to a Monistary, and become monks, women to the convent to be nuns) I think if you read between the lines you can see that he probably was an operative and like you say, Had to retire to seek atonement for the sins he commited and emerged a shepard. In the few quotes I can remember of the top of my head “I wasnt borne a preacher”
      and “No, they wont, they will come at you sideways”and the fact that he never hesitated to shoot and nail what he was aiming at. Granted as the shepard he would aim for non leathel targets. (of which Mal usually finished off the job LOLOL)
      Ithink this will be one of our unfinished stories.

  2. William says:

    I think you are on the right track but reach the wrong conclusion. Shepard Book is AN operative, not THE operative. The suspension of disbelief required to digest sci-fi and fantasy does not extend to the order of magnitude necessary for such a leap as your conclusion suggests. There is nothing suggestive of “time travel” in the series, which is very practical in scope and more in tune with very early space travel sci-fi adventure. Every empire has assassins and the Alliance has existed for enough years that generations of such operatives could have retired. Book is one of those. Likely “The Operative” has now disappeared into a monastery for contemplation of his own failures just as Book did before him.

  3. Scott says:

    That’s a fantastic idea, mariflies; it certainly fits a lot of the available facts, plus has the allure of not being immediately obvious (except, I suppose, to you, since you conceived it), as well as presenting a very intriguing causality loop. It’s really unfortunate that it’s unlikely to be explored more fully. I was wondering if you’ve had the chance to read “Serenity: The Shepherd’s Tale” yet; though I like your idea better, it presents a different backstory for Book than the one you propose.

  4. Edward Anderson says:

    Why does it need to be so remarkably complicated as this, with Time Travel and all? What if “Shepherd” Book was involved in the program which created the Operatives. “Apologies, an operative of the Parliament will of course have full cooperation…” It’s established in the first ten minutes of the movie that there could well be MANY Operatives. To my thinking, I could sooner believe that Book was part of the program which produced these Operatives, and that perhaps Early was a reject of this program. This would be too much coincidence, even for the Whedonverse, but FAR more believable in a universe which has sub-luminal drives, no aliens and lacks anything like Teleportation.

  5. Christopher says:

    I have always thought of him as an “Operative”. Personally I was quite dismayed that his back story in the graphic novel was such a blatant disconnect from the Firefly and Serenity series. There was such a richer satisfying story to be told.

    • Windwalker says:

      I have to agree. I own “The Shepard’s Tale”, and although it was entertaining, it was also disappointing. Plus, the graphic novel (GN) history doesn’t quite add up in the show: When Book is hurt badly, he is given this HUGE amount of respect/attention/etc on the Federation ship when they find out who he is. But I can’t imagine he would have received that kind of respect if the GN histiry was his story…

      • Weeman Sandman says:

        Exactly. I was so disappointed with that. It’s almost like if a dishonorable discharge got you anything you need in our “‘verse.”

  6. Craig says:

    According to the Firefly graphic novel “A Shepherd’s Tale”, Book was a double agent working undercover for the Independents while maintaining his cover as a torturer for the Alliance. He made his way up the ranks of the Alliance until he lost a crucial battle against the Independence at which point he was disgraced and retired to a monastery. After some years he left the monastery for a journey to the “wilderness” to find himself at which point he met Serenity. The rest is history.

    • Merritt says:

      Would have thought the graphic novel response would have been the first reply to this essay. While having Book be a former Operative is kind of appealing, I do like what they did in “A Shepherd’s Tale” far better.

      • Paul B says:

        But that whole undercover agent for the rebel alliance (sorry, crossed references there) has a big gaping hole in it. If he was disgraced and retired to a monastery, why did they jump through hoops to give him medical treatment when he was shot? The Alliance doesn’t strike me as particularly helpful once they decide to drum someone out… I dunno, doesn’t jive for me.

        I’ve always leaned toward the former Operative angle, myself…

        • Windwalker says:

          I have to agree with you, Paul. The Alliance wouldn’t spend so much time helping Book out if he was a disgraced officer.

  7. Andy says:

    I agree that Book was a former operative that had lost his conviction in what he was doing, much like the operative from “Serenity” did at the conclusion of the film. Even his dying words to Mal are “I don’t care what you believe in, just believe in something” He was in a way telling Mal what he was in the past. He was referring to the statement that he had made to Mal about the operative when the crew first visits Haven when hes said that you couldn’t stop a man that believed that what he was doing was right. (i’m paraphrasing) Book’s last words are what made it click for me. I thought…”he is a former operative, and he is telling Mal how to beat the operative that is after River.” I agree with William’s comment. Likely “The Operative” has now disappeared into a monastery for contemplation of his own failures just as Book did before him.

  8. Heathe says:

    Theories are all fine and good when we don’t know any different – but clearly you haven’t read “A Shepherd’s Tale” or else you would KNOW Book’s backstory. And no, he’s not an Operative.

    • Rain says:

      Thank You!!

    • Windwalker says:

      True, Heathe, but, like the Star Wars books, this graphic novel does not build precedence. Just because there is a book out saying something, that doesn’t make it the canon for the character. It’s just one person’s creativity filling a void.

  9. Rain says:

    I am shaking my head to your pure ignorance of Book! Everything (or nearly everything) you need/want to know is clearly laid out in “A Shepard’s Tale” by Zack Whedon.

  10. Bill Miller says:

    Heathe, Did Josh write the graphic novel, I truly don’t know as I have not read it. But all ‘popular stories’ generate back stories from internal and external (fan fiction) ranks. More than once the ‘fan fiction’ has become the highly regarded story and the ‘establishment’ story quietly passes into oblivion. The second iteration here (sans time bending) makes great sense, and just feels right, also explaining why Books secret place was so viciously attacked, once the operative ascertained who he was. IMNSHO

Speak Your Mind

*